白起王翦列傳 (Biographies of Bai Qi and Wang Jian) — Chinese ink painting

Chapter 73 of 130

白起王翦列傳

Biographies of Bai Qi and Wang Jian

View:

白起早年征戰

Bai Qi's Early Campaigns

白起者,郿人也。善用兵,事秦昭王。昭王十三年,而白起為左庶長,將而擊韓之新城。是歲,穰侯相秦,舉任鄙以為漢中守。其明年,白起為左更,攻韓、魏於伊闕,斬首二十四萬,又虜其將公孫喜,拔五城。起遷為國尉。涉河取韓安邑以東,到乾河。明年,白起為大良造。攻魏,拔之,取城小大六十一。明年,起與客卿錯攻垣城,拔之。後五年,白起攻趙,拔光狼城。後七年,白起攻楚,拔鄢、鄧五城。其明年,攻楚,拔郢,燒夷陵,遂東至竟陵。楚王亡去郢,東走徙陳。秦以郢為南郡。白起遷為武安君。武安君因取楚,定巫、黔中郡。昭王三十四年,白起攻魏,拔華陽,走芒卯,而虜三晉將,斬首十三萬。與趙將賈偃戰,沈其卒二萬人於河中。昭王四十三年,白起攻韓陘城,拔五城,斬首五萬。四十四年,白起攻南陽太行道,絕之。

Bai Qi was a native of Mei. He excelled at warfare and served King Zhao of Qin. In the thirteenth year of King Zhao's reign, Bai Qi held the rank of Left Shuchang and led an attack on Han's city of Xincheng. That year, the Marquis of Rang served as Qin's chancellor and appointed Ren Bi as governor of Hanzhong.

The following year, Bai Qi was promoted to Left Geng and attacked Han and Wei at Yique. He took 240,000 heads, captured their general Gongsun Xi, and seized five cities. He was promoted to National Commandant. He crossed the Yellow River and took the territory east of Han's Anyi as far as the Qian River.

The next year, Bai Qi was made Grand Master of Works. He attacked Wei, took it, and captured sixty-one cities large and small. The year after, Bai Qi and the guest minister Cuo attacked the walled city of Yuan and took it.

Five years later, Bai Qi attacked Zhao and took Guanglang. Seven years after that, he attacked Chu and seized Yan, Deng, and five cities. The following year, he attacked Chu again, captured its capital Ying, burned Yiling, and advanced east as far as Jingling. The King of Chu abandoned Ying and fled east to resettle at Chen. Qin made Ying the seat of Nan Commandery. Bai Qi was enfeoffed as Lord of Wu'an.

Lord Wu'an then continued the conquest of Chu, pacifying the Wu and Qianzhong commanderies. In the thirty-fourth year of King Zhao, Bai Qi attacked Wei, took Huayang, routed Mang Mao, captured generals of the Three Jin, and took 130,000 heads. He fought the Zhao general Jia Yan and drowned 20,000 of his soldiers in the Yellow River.

In the forty-third year of King Zhao, Bai Qi attacked Han's city of Xing and took five cities, beheading 50,000. In the forty-fourth year, he cut the Taihang road through Nanyang, severing it completely.

Notes

1person秦昭襄王Qín Zhāo Xiāng Wáng

King Zhao of Qin (秦昭襄王, r. 306–251 BC) was one of the longest-reigning and most aggressive Qin monarchs. His reign saw Qin's decisive shift from regional power to the dominant state in All-Under-Heaven.

2place

Mei (郿) was in modern Mei County (眉縣), Shaanxi, in the Wei River valley west of the Qin capital Xianyang.

3context

The Battle of Yique (伊闕之戰, 293 BC) was one of the most devastating battles of the Warring States. The 240,000 figure — whether casualties or heads taken — established Bai Qi's fearsome reputation. Yique (modern Longmen, south of Luoyang) was a strategic gorge controlling access to the central plains.

4person魏冉Wèi Rǎn

The Marquis of Rang (穰侯) was Wei Ran (魏冉), Queen Dowager Xuan's brother and the power behind the Qin throne for decades. He controlled Qin's military appointments until his fall from power.

5place

Ying (郢) was the Chu capital for centuries, located near modern Jiangling, Hubei. Its fall in 278 BC was a catastrophic blow to Chu — it was during this crisis that the poet Qu Yuan drowned himself in the Miluo River.

6context

The title Lord of Wu'an (武安君) literally means 'Lord Who Pacifies by Force.' It was one of the highest honorific titles a military commander could receive. Ironically, the same title was later given to Li Mu of Zhao, who would be Qin's most formidable opponent.

7context

The Three Jin (三晉) refers to Han, Wei, and Zhao — the three successor states that partitioned the old state of Jin in 403 BC. They shared borders with Qin and bore the brunt of its expansion.

上黨之爭與長平之戰

The Shangdang Dispute and the Battle of Changping

四十五年,伐韓之野王。野王降秦,上黨道絕。其守馮亭與民謀曰:"鄭道已絕,韓必不可得為民。秦兵日進,韓不能應,不如以上黨歸趙。趙若受我,秦怒,必攻趙。趙被兵,必親韓。韓趙為一,則可以當秦。"因使人報趙。趙孝成王與平陽君、平原君計之。平陽君曰:"不如勿受。受之,禍大於所得。"平原君曰:"無故得一郡,受之便。"趙受之,因封馮亭為華陽君。

四十六年,秦攻韓緱氏、藺,拔之。

四十七年,秦使左庶長王齕攻韓,取上黨。上黨民走趙。趙軍長平,以按據上黨民。四月,齕因攻趙。趙使廉頗將。趙軍士卒犯秦斥兵,秦斥兵斬趙裨將茄。六月,陷趙軍,取二鄣四尉。七月,趙軍築壘壁而守之。秦又攻其壘,取二尉,敗其陣,奪西壘壁。廉頗堅壁以待秦,秦數挑戰,趙兵不出。趙王數以為讓。而秦相應侯又使人行千金於趙為反間,曰:"秦之所惡,獨畏馬服子趙括將耳,廉頗易與,且降矣。"趙王既怒廉頗軍多失亡,軍數敗,又反堅壁不敢戰,而又聞秦反間之言,因使趙括代廉頗將以擊秦。秦聞馬服子將,乃陰使武安君白起為上將軍。而王齕為尉裨將,令軍中有敢泄武安君將者斬。趙括至,則出兵擊秦軍。秦軍詳敗而走,張二奇兵以劫之。趙軍逐勝,追造秦壁。壁堅拒不得入,而秦奇兵二萬五千人絕趙軍後,又一軍五千騎絕趙壁間,趙軍分而為二,糧道絕。而秦出輕兵擊之。趙戰不利,因築壁堅守,以待救至。秦王聞趙食道絕,王自之河內,賜民爵各一級,發年十五以上悉詣長平,遮絕趙救及糧食。

至九月,趙卒不得食四十六日,皆內陰相殺食。來攻秦壘,欲出。為四隊,四五復之,不能出。其將軍趙括出銳卒自搏戰,秦軍射殺趙括。括軍敗,卒四十萬人降武安君。武安君計曰:"前秦已拔上黨,上黨民不樂為秦而歸趙。趙卒反覆。非盡殺之,恐為亂。"乃挾詐而盡阬殺之,遺其小者二百四十人歸趙。前後斬首虜四十五萬人。趙人大震。

In the forty-fifth year, Qin attacked Han's city of Yewang. Yewang surrendered, and the road to the Shangdang commandery was severed. The Shangdang governor Feng Ting discussed the situation with his people: "The road south is cut off. Han can no longer protect us. Qin's armies advance daily and Han cannot resist. We would do better to offer Shangdang to Zhao. If Zhao accepts us, Qin will be furious and attack Zhao. Once Zhao is at war, it will draw close to Han. If Han and Zhao unite, they can stand against Qin." He sent envoys to Zhao.

King Xiaocheng of Zhao discussed the matter with Lord Pingyang and Lord Pingyuan. Lord Pingyang said: "We should not accept. The disaster it brings will be greater than the gain." Lord Pingyuan said: "To gain a whole commandery for nothing — we should take it." Zhao accepted, and enfeoffed Feng Ting as Lord Huayang.

In the forty-sixth year, Qin attacked Han's cities of Goushi and Lin and took them.

In the forty-seventh year, Qin sent the Left Shuchang Wang He to attack Han and seize Shangdang. The Shangdang people fled to Zhao. Zhao garrisoned Changping to shelter the Shangdang refugees. In the fourth month, Wang He attacked Zhao in turn. Zhao sent Lian Po to command.

Zhao's soldiers engaged Qin's scouts, and Qin's scouts killed Zhao's assistant general Qie. In the sixth month, Qin broke through a Zhao position, capturing two strongpoints and four officers. In the seventh month, Zhao's army built ramparts and held a defensive position. Qin attacked the ramparts, captured two more officers, broke their formation, and seized the western wall. Lian Po fortified his position and waited, refusing battle despite Qin's repeated provocations. The King of Zhao criticized him repeatedly.

Meanwhile, Qin's chancellor the Marquis of Ying sent agents with a thousand jin of gold into Zhao to spread disinformation: "The only man Qin fears is Zhao Kuo, son of the Lord of Mafu. Lian Po is easy to handle — he is on the verge of surrender." The King of Zhao was already angry that Lian Po's forces had suffered losses and repeated setbacks, and that he stubbornly held his fortifications and refused to fight. Hearing the Qin-planted rumors, he replaced Lian Po with Zhao Kuo.

When Qin learned that the son of Lord Mafu had taken command, they secretly appointed Lord Wu'an — Bai Qi — as supreme commander. Wang He was demoted to deputy, and orders went out that any soldier who revealed Bai Qi's presence would be executed.

When Zhao Kuo arrived, he immediately attacked. Qin's forces feigned defeat and retreated. Two ambush forces closed the trap. Zhao's army pursued what it thought was a rout and reached the Qin ramparts, which held firm. A Qin detachment of 25,000 cut behind the Zhao army, and another force of 5,000 cavalry split the Zhao position in two. The supply lines were severed. Qin sent light troops to harass them. Zhao's attacks failed; they fortified their position and waited for relief.

The King of Qin, learning that Zhao's supply route was cut, traveled personally to Henei. He granted every commoner a promotion in rank and conscripted all males aged fifteen and above, sending them to Changping to block any Zhao reinforcements or supplies.

By the ninth month, Zhao's soldiers had gone forty-six days without food. They were secretly killing and eating each other. They launched four assaults on the Qin ramparts, trying to break out, attacking in four columns and repeating the attempt four or five times, but could not get through. General Zhao Kuo led his best troops in a personal charge and was killed by Qin archers.

With Zhao Kuo dead, his army collapsed. Four hundred thousand soldiers surrendered to Lord Wu'an. Bai Qi calculated: "Qin already took Shangdang, but the Shangdang people refused to become Qin subjects and went over to Zhao. These Zhao soldiers cannot be trusted — if we do not kill them all, they will cause trouble." He tricked them and buried them alive, sparing only 240 of the youngest to send back to Zhao as a warning. In all, 450,000 were killed or captured. The people of Zhao were shaken to their core.

Notes

1context

The Battle of Changping (長平之戰, 260 BC) was the single largest and most devastating battle of the Warring States period. The burial alive (坑殺) of 400,000 surrendered soldiers made Bai Qi the most feared — and most hated — military figure in Chinese history. The battle effectively ended Zhao's ability to challenge Qin.

2place

Shangdang (上黨) literally means 'high ground.' It was the elevated plateau region of southeastern Shanxi, a strategically critical territory because it overlooked the Zhao capital Handan to the east and the Qin heartland to the west.

3place

Changping (長平) was near modern Gaoping, Shanxi. Extensive archaeological excavations have uncovered mass burial pits consistent with Sima Qian's account.

4person趙孝成王Zhào Xiào Chéng Wáng

King Xiaocheng of Zhao (趙孝成王, r. 265–245 BC) made the fateful decision to accept Shangdang and later to replace Lian Po with Zhao Kuo — the two decisions that led directly to the Changping disaster.

5person趙勝Zhào Shèng

Lord Pingyuan (平原君, d. 251 BC) was Zhao Sheng (趙勝), one of the famous 'Four Lords of the Warring States' (戰國四公子). His advice to accept Shangdang proved disastrous.

6person范雎Fàn Suī

The Marquis of Ying (應侯) was Fan Sui (范雎), Qin's chancellor. He masterminded the disinformation campaign against Lian Po. His later rivalry with Bai Qi would contribute to the general's downfall.

7person趙括Zhào Kuò

Zhao Kuo (趙括) was the son of the great general Zhao She (趙奢, Lord of Mafu). He was well-read in military theory but had no practical experience. His name became a byword for armchair strategists — the idiom 紙上談兵 ('discussing war on paper') derives from his story.

8person廉頗Lián Pō

Lian Po (廉頗) was one of Zhao's greatest generals. His defensive strategy at Changping was militarily sound — by avoiding pitched battle, he denied Qin a decisive victory and strained Qin's long supply lines. Zhao's impatience cost them everything.

9place

Henei (河內) was the region north of the Yellow River bend in modern northern Henan and southern Shanxi. The King of Qin's personal journey there to mobilize the population shows how seriously Qin took this campaign.

白起之死

The Death of Bai Qi

四十八年十月,秦復定上黨郡。秦分軍為二:王齕攻皮牢,拔之;司馬梗定太原。韓、趙恐,使蘇代厚幣說秦相應侯曰:"武安君禽馬服子乎?"曰:"然。"又曰:"即圍邯鄲乎?"曰:"然。""趙亡則秦王王矣,武安君為三公。武安君所為秦戰勝攻取者七十餘城,南定鄢、郢、漢中,北禽趙括之軍,雖周、召、呂望之功不益於此矣。今趙亡,秦王王,則武安君必為三公,君能為之下乎?雖無欲為之下,固不得已矣。秦嘗攻韓,圍邢丘,困上黨,上黨之民皆反為趙,天下不樂為秦民之日久矣。今亡趙,北地入燕,東地入齊,南地入韓、魏,則君之所得民亡幾何人。故不如因而割之,無以為武安君功也。"於是應侯言於秦王曰:"秦兵勞,請許韓、趙之割地以和,且休士卒。"王聽之,割韓垣雍、趙六城以和。正月,皆罷兵。武安君聞之,由是與應侯有隙。

其九月,秦復發兵,使五大夫王陵攻趙邯鄲。是時武安君病,不任行。四十九年正月,陵攻邯鄲,少利,秦益發兵佐陵。陵兵亡五校。武安君病癒,秦王欲使武安君代陵將。武安君言曰:"邯鄲實未易攻也。且諸侯救日至,彼諸侯怨秦之日久矣。今秦雖破長平軍,而秦卒死者過半,國內空。遠絕河山而爭人國都,趙應其內,諸侯攻其外,破秦軍必矣。不可。"秦王自命,不行;乃使應侯請之,武安君終辭不肯行,遂稱病。

秦王使王齕代陵將,八九月圍邯鄲,不能拔。楚使春申君及魏公子將兵數十萬攻秦軍,秦軍多失亡。武安君言曰:"秦不聽臣計,今如何矣!"秦王聞之,怒,彊起武安君,武安君遂稱病篤。應侯請之,不起。於是免武安君為士伍,遷之陰密。武安君病,未能行。居三月,諸侯攻秦軍急,秦軍數卻,使者日至。秦王乃使人遣白起,不得留鹹陽中。武安君既行,出鹹陽西門十里,至杜郵。秦昭王與應侯群臣議曰:"白起之遷,其意尚怏怏不服,有餘言。"秦王乃使使者賜之劍,自裁。武安君引劍將自剄,曰:"我何罪於天而至此哉?"良久,曰:"我固當死。長平之戰,趙卒降者數十萬人,我詐而盡阬之,是足以死。"遂自殺。武安君之死也,以秦昭王五十年十一月。死而非其罪,秦人憐之,鄉邑皆祭祀焉。

In the tenth month of the forty-eighth year, Qin re-established control over the Shangdang commandery. Qin divided its forces: Wang He attacked Pilao and took it; Sima Geng pacified Taiyuan. Han and Zhao were terrified and sent Su Dai with lavish gifts to persuade Qin's chancellor, the Marquis of Ying.

Su Dai asked: "Was it Lord Wu'an who captured the son of Lord Mafu?"

"It was."

"And will you now besiege Handan?"

"We will."

"If Zhao falls, the King of Qin will become supreme ruler, and Lord Wu'an will be made one of the Three Excellencies. Lord Wu'an has conquered over seventy cities for Qin, pacified Yan and Ying and Hanzhong in the south, and captured Zhao Kuo's army in the north. Not even the Duke of Zhou, the Duke of Shao, or Lyu Wang achieved more than this. Once Zhao falls and the King of Qin reigns supreme, Lord Wu'an will certainly become one of the Three Excellencies. Can you serve beneath him? Even if you do not wish to, you will have no choice.

"Moreover, when Qin attacked Han and besieged Xingqiu and pressed Shangdang, the Shangdang people all defected to Zhao. The people of the world have long been unwilling to become Qin subjects. If you destroy Zhao now, its northern territories will go to Yan, its eastern lands to Qi, its southern lands to Han and Wei — how many people will Qin actually gain? Better to accept a territorial settlement and deny Lord Wu'an the credit."

The Marquis of Ying was persuaded. He told the King of Qin: "Our troops are exhausted. Let us accept Han and Zhao's offer of territory for peace, and give the soldiers rest." The king agreed. Han ceded Yuanyong and Zhao ceded six cities. In the first month, all armies were withdrawn. When Lord Wu'an learned of this, a rift opened between him and the Marquis of Ying.

In the ninth month, Qin raised troops again and sent the Fifth-Rank Grandee Wang Ling to attack Zhao's capital Handan. Lord Wu'an was ill and unable to march. In the first month of the forty-ninth year, Wang Ling made little progress against Handan, and Qin sent reinforcements. Wang Ling lost five battalions. Lord Wu'an recovered from his illness, and the King of Qin wanted him to replace Wang Ling.

Lord Wu'an said: "Handan is genuinely difficult to take. The other states are sending relief forces daily, and they have resented Qin for a long time. Although we destroyed the Zhao army at Changping, more than half our own soldiers died and the country is drained. To cross rivers and mountains to fight for another state's capital — with Zhao defending from within and the other states attacking from without — our army will certainly be destroyed. It cannot be done."

The king ordered him personally. He refused. The king sent the Marquis of Ying to plead. Lord Wu'an refused a final time and declared himself too ill to serve.

The king sent Wang He to replace Wang Ling. For months Wang He besieged Handan without success. Chu sent Lord Chunshen and Wei sent Lord Xinling with hundreds of thousands of troops to attack the Qin army. Qin suffered heavy losses.

Lord Wu'an remarked: "The king would not listen to my advice. Now look at the result."

The King of Qin heard this and was furious. He forced Lord Wu'an to rise from his sickbed, but Bai Qi declared his illness severe. The Marquis of Ying went to summon him; he would not move. The king then stripped Bai Qi of his title and rank, reducing him to common soldier, and ordered his exile to Yinmi.

Bai Qi was too ill to travel. Three months passed. The other states pressed their attacks on Qin's army, which fell back repeatedly. Couriers arrived at the capital daily with bad news. The King of Qin ordered Bai Qi expelled — he could no longer remain in Xianyang.

Lord Wu'an set out. Ten li west of Xianyang's western gate, he reached Duyou. The King of Qin conferred with the Marquis of Ying and his ministers: "Bai Qi departed resentful and unrepentant, with bitter words on his lips."

The king sent a messenger with a sword, ordering Bai Qi to take his own life.

Lord Wu'an drew the sword and was about to cut his throat. He said: "What crime have I committed against Heaven to come to this?"

After a long silence, he said: "I deserve to die. At the Battle of Changping, hundreds of thousands of Zhao soldiers surrendered, and I tricked them and buried them all alive. That alone is enough to warrant death."

He killed himself. Lord Wu'an died in the eleventh month of King Zhao's fiftieth year. He died without deserving it, and the people of Qin pitied him. The villages and towns all made sacrifices in his memory.

Notes

1person蘇代Sū Dài

Su Dai (蘇代) was a diplomat and younger brother of the famous persuader Su Qin. His argument to the Marquis of Ying is a masterclass in exploiting court rivalries — he correctly identified that Fan Sui feared Bai Qi's prestige more than he feared Zhao's survival.

2context

The Three Excellencies (三公) were the highest offices below the ruler — Grand Preceptor, Grand Mentor, and Grand Protector. Su Dai's argument is that Bai Qi's military achievements already surpass all historical precedent, and further conquests would make him impossible for the chancellor to control.

3place

Handan (邯鄲), the Zhao capital, was in modern Handan, Hebei. The siege of Handan (259–257 BC) is one of the great set pieces of Warring States history, featuring Lord Xinling's theft of the military tally to save Zhao.

4person春申君 / 信陵君Chūn Shēn Jūn / Xìn Líng Jūn

Lord Chunshen (春申君) was Huang Xie (黃歇, d. 238 BC), chief minister of Chu and another of the 'Four Lords of the Warring States.' Lord Xinling (信陵君) was Wei Wuji (魏無忌, d. 243 BC) of Wei, the most admired of the four. His dramatic theft of the Tiger Tally to commandeer Wei's army and rescue Zhao is told in Shiji ch. 77.

5place

Duyou (杜郵) was a post station ten li west of Xianyang, near modern Xianyang, Shaanxi. It became famous solely as the place where Bai Qi was forced to die.

6context

Bai Qi's final words — his initial protest of innocence followed by his self-condemnation for the Changping massacre — are among the most psychologically complex passages in the Shiji. Sima Qian presents a man who first sees himself as a victim of court politics, then, in a moment of moral clarity, acknowledges that the mass killing of surrendered soldiers was an inexpiable crime regardless of its military rationale.

7context

Bai Qi's strategic analysis of why Handan could not be taken proved entirely correct. The combined forces of Chu, Wei, and Zhao did break the siege. His refusal to command a doomed campaign shows genuine strategic insight, but in Qin's autocratic system, a general who refused the king's order — however right he was — could not survive.

王翦滅六國

Wang Jian and the Conquest of the Six States

王翦者,頻陽東鄉人也。少而好兵,事秦始皇。始皇十一年,翦將攻趙閼與,破之,拔九城,十八年,翦將攻趙。歲餘,遂拔趙,趙王降,盡定趙地為郡。明年,燕使荊軻為賊於秦,秦王使王翦攻燕。燕王喜走遼東,翦遂定燕薊而還。秦使翦子王賁擊荊,荊兵敗。還擊魏,魏王降,遂定魏地。

Wang Jian was a native of the eastern district of Pinyang. From youth he loved the art of war and served the First Emperor of Qin.

In the eleventh year of the First Emperor's reign, Wang Jian led an attack on Zhao's stronghold at Eyu, broke through, and captured nine cities. In the eighteenth year, he led a full-scale invasion of Zhao. After more than a year of campaigning, he conquered Zhao. The King of Zhao surrendered, and the entire territory of Zhao was organized into commanderies.

The following year, Yan sent Jing Ke to assassinate the King of Qin. The king sent Wang Jian to attack Yan. King Xi of Yan fled to Liaodong, and Wang Jian pacified the Yan capital Ji before returning.

Qin then sent Wang Jian's son Wang Ben to attack Chu. Chu's forces were defeated. Wang Ben then turned to attack Wei. The King of Wei surrendered, and Wei's territory was pacified.

Notes

1place

Pinyang (頻陽) was in modern Fuping County, Shaanxi, northeast of the Qin capital.

2person秦始皇Qín Shǐ Huáng

The First Emperor of Qin (秦始皇, r. 246–210 BC as King of Qin, Emperor from 221 BC) was Ying Zheng (嬴政). Wang Jian was his most trusted general and the principal military architect of unification.

3context

Jing Ke's assassination attempt (227 BC) is one of the most famous episodes in Chinese history, told in detail in Shiji ch. 86. Jing Ke concealed a poisoned dagger in a map scroll and nearly killed the King of Qin at close quarters. The attempt failed and gave Qin the pretext for an immediate invasion of Yan.

4place

Ji (薊) was the Yan capital, located at modern Beijing. Liaodong (遼東) was the remote northeastern frontier — King Xi's flight there only delayed Yan's destruction by a few years.

王翦伐楚:六十萬大軍

Wang Jian's Conquest of Chu: The Sixty-Thousand-Man Army

秦始皇既滅三晉,走燕王,而數破荊師。秦將李信者,年少壯勇,嘗以兵數千逐燕太子丹至於衍水中,卒破得丹,始皇以為賢勇。於是始皇問李信:"吾欲攻取荊,於將軍度用幾何人而足?"李信曰:"不過用二十萬人。"始皇問王翦,王翦曰:"非六十萬人不可。"始皇曰:"王將軍老矣,何怯也!李將軍果勢壯勇,其言是也。"遂使李信及蒙恬將二十萬南伐荊。王翦言不用,因謝病,歸老於頻陽。李信攻平與,蒙恬攻寢,大破荊軍。信又攻鄢郢,破之,於是引兵而西,與蒙恬會城父。荊人因隨之,三日三夜不頓舍,大破李信軍,入兩壁,殺七都尉,秦軍走。

始皇聞之,大怒,自馳如頻陽,見謝王翦曰:"寡人以不用將軍計,李信果辱秦軍。今聞荊兵日進而西,將軍雖病,獨忍棄寡人乎!"王翦謝曰:"老臣罷病悖亂,唯大王更擇賢將。"始皇謝曰:"已矣,將軍勿復言!"王翦曰:"大王必不得已用臣,非六十萬人不可。"始皇曰:"為聽將軍計耳。"於是王翦將兵六十萬人,始皇自送至灞上。王翦行,請美田宅園池甚眾。始皇曰:"將軍行矣,何憂貧乎?"王翦曰:"為大王將,有功終不得封侯,故及大王之鄉臣,臣亦及時以請園池為子孫業耳。"始皇大笑。王翦既至關,使使還請善田者五輩。或曰:"將軍之乞貸,亦已甚矣。"王翦曰:"不然。夫秦王怚而不信人。今空秦國甲士而專委於我,我不多請田宅為子孫業以自堅,顧令秦王坐而疑我邪?"

王翦果代李信擊荊。荊聞王翦益軍而來,乃悉國中兵以拒秦。王翦至,堅壁而守之,不肯戰。荊兵數出挑戰,終不出。王翦日休士洗沐,而善飲食撫循之,親與士卒同食。久之,王翦使人問軍中戲乎?對曰:"方投石超距。"於是王翦曰:"士卒可用矣。"荊數挑戰而秦不出,乃引而東。翦因舉兵追之,令壯士擊,大破荊軍。至蘄南,殺其將軍項燕,荊兵遂敗走。秦因乘勝略定荊地城邑。歲餘,虜荊王負芻,竟平荊地為郡縣。因南征百越之君。而王翦子王賁,與李信破定燕、齊地。

The First Emperor had already destroyed the Three Jin and driven the King of Yan into flight, and had defeated Chu's armies several times. A Qin general named Li Xin was young, vigorous, and bold. He had once pursued Crown Prince Dan of Yan with only a few thousand troops to the Yan River and captured him. The First Emperor considered him exceptionally brave.

The emperor asked Li Xin: "I intend to conquer Chu. In your estimation, how many troops would be sufficient?"

Li Xin said: "No more than two hundred thousand."

The emperor asked Wang Jian the same question. Wang Jian said: "It cannot be done with fewer than six hundred thousand."

The emperor said: "General Wang is old. How timid he has become! General Li is the picture of vigor and courage — his estimate is correct." He sent Li Xin and Meng Tian south with two hundred thousand troops to attack Chu.

Wang Jian, his counsel rejected, pleaded illness and retired to Pinyang.

Li Xin attacked Pingyu, and Meng Tian attacked Qin — both won great victories. Li Xin then attacked Yanying and took it, then wheeled west to rendezvous with Meng Tian at Chengfu. But the Chu forces shadowed them, pursuing for three days and three nights without rest, then smashed Li Xin's army, storming two camps and killing seven commandants. The Qin army fled.

The First Emperor was furious. He personally raced to Pinyang, met Wang Jian, and apologized: "I failed to heed your advice, and Li Xin has disgraced our army. Now I hear Chu's forces advance west daily. General, even if you are ill, can you bear to abandon me?"

Wang Jian demurred: "This old minister is worn out and confused. Your Majesty should choose a better general."

The emperor said: "Enough — say no more."

Wang Jian said: "If Your Majesty insists on using me, it cannot be done with fewer than six hundred thousand."

The emperor said: "We will follow your plan."

Wang Jian took command of six hundred thousand troops. The First Emperor personally escorted him as far as Bashang. As Wang Jian departed, he requested generous grants of fine farmland, houses, and gardens.

The emperor said: "You are about to march, General. Why worry about poverty?"

Wang Jian said: "Serving as Your Majesty's general, even with achievements I would never be enfeoffed. So while Your Majesty still looks on me with favor, I should at least secure estates and gardens as an inheritance for my descendants."

The emperor laughed heartily.

After Wang Jian passed through the pass, he sent messengers back five times to request more prime farmland. Someone said to him: "General, is this begging not rather excessive?"

Wang Jian said: "Not at all. The King of Qin is suspicious by nature and trusts no one. He has now emptied the entire country of its fighting men and placed them all under my sole command. If I do not keep requesting estates for my descendants to prove I have no greater ambitions, I will give the King of Qin cause to sit in his palace and suspect me."

Wang Jian replaced Li Xin and marched against Chu. When Chu heard that Wang Jian was coming with an enlarged army, they mobilized every soldier in the kingdom to resist.

Wang Jian arrived, built fortified camps, and refused to fight. Chu's forces repeatedly came out to provoke battle; he would not engage. Every day he let his soldiers rest, bathe, eat well, and be looked after. He personally ate the same food as the troops. After a long time, Wang Jian sent someone to ask what the soldiers were doing for recreation. The answer came back: "They are throwing stones and doing long jumps."

Wang Jian said: "The troops are ready."

Chu had challenged again and again without response. They gave up and began marching east. Wang Jian immediately launched a pursuit, sending his best fighters to strike. Chu's army was shattered. He drove south to Qi, where he killed their commander Xiang Yan. Chu's forces collapsed and fled.

Qin pressed its advantage, sweeping through Chu's cities and towns. After a year, they captured King Fuchu of Chu and reduced all of Chu's territory to commanderies and counties. From there, they campaigned south to subdue the lords of the Baiyue.

Wang Jian's son Wang Ben, together with Li Xin, completed the conquest of Yan and Qi.

Notes

1person李信Lǐ Xìn

Li Xin (李信) was a daring young Qin general. His disastrous defeat in Chu (225 BC) remains one of the few serious military setbacks Qin suffered during the wars of unification. He later served under Wang Ben in the conquest of Yan and Qi, suggesting the First Emperor did not permanently disgrace him.

2person蒙恬Méng Tián

Meng Tian (蒙恬, d. 210 BC) later became famous for commanding 300,000 troops to build the Great Wall and defend against the Xiongnu. He was forced to commit suicide after the First Emperor's death.

3person項燕Xiàng Yān

Xiang Yan (項燕) was the supreme Chu commander. He was the grandfather of Xiang Yu (項羽), the 'Hegemon-King of Western Chu' who would destroy Qin's dynasty a generation later. The Xiang clan's desire for vengeance over Xiang Yan's death was a driving force of the anti-Qin rebellion.

4context

Wang Jian's strategy of repeatedly requesting estates is one of the most celebrated examples of political self-preservation in Chinese history. By appearing greedy and small-minded, he reassured the suspicious First Emperor that he harbored no ambitions beyond personal wealth — and thus no intention of using 600,000 troops to rebel. The contrast with Bai Qi, who failed to manage his king's suspicions and died for it, is implicit.

5context

Wang Jian's tactics against Chu mirror Lian Po's defensive strategy at Changping — patiently refusing battle until the enemy's morale crumbled. But where Zhao's king lost patience with Lian Po, the First Emperor had learned from Li Xin's failure and gave Wang Jian the time he needed. Wang Jian's test — asking whether the soldiers were throwing stones and competing in athletics — told him they were bored, well-fed, and itching for action.

6place

Bashang (灞上) was a plateau east of the Qin capital Xianyang, near the Ba River. It was the traditional departure point for armies marching east.

王氏三世與太史公論贊

Three Generations of the Wang Clan and Sima Qian's Appraisal

秦始皇二十六年,盡並天下,王氏、蒙氏功為多,名施於後世。

秦二世之時,王翦及其子賁皆已死,而又滅蒙氏。陳勝之反秦,秦使王翦之孫王離擊趙,圍趙王及張耳鉅鹿城。或曰:"王離,秦之名將也。今將彊秦之兵,攻新造之趙,舉之必矣。"客曰:"不然。夫為將三世者必敗。必敗者何也?必其所殺伐多矣,其後受其不祥。今王離已三世將矣。"居無何,項羽救趙,擊秦軍,果虜王離,王離軍遂降諸侯。

太史公曰:鄙語云"尺有所短,寸有所長"。白起料敵合變,出奇無窮,聲震天下,然不能救患於應侯。王翦為秦將,夷六國,當是時,翦為宿將,始皇師之,然不能輔秦建德,固其根本,偷合取容,以至筊身。及孫王離為項羽所虜,不亦宜乎!彼各有所短也。

白起、王翦,俱善用兵。遞為秦將,拔齊破荊。趙任馬服,長平遂阬。楚陷李信,霸上卒行。賁、離繼出,三代無名。

In the twenty-sixth year of the First Emperor, the world was unified. The Wang and Meng clans had contributed the most and their fame extended to later generations.

By the time of the Second Emperor, Wang Jian and his son Ben had both died, and the Meng clan had been exterminated. When Chen Sheng rebelled against Qin, Wang Jian's grandson Wang Li was sent to attack Zhao, besieging the King of Zhao and Zhang Er at Julu.

Someone said: "Wang Li is a famous Qin general. Leading the mighty Qin army against the newly established Zhao, he will certainly take it."

A guest replied: "Not so. A family that produces generals for three generations will inevitably be defeated. Why must they be defeated? Because they must have killed vast numbers, and their descendants will inherit the curse. Wang Li is already the third generation."

Before long, Xiang Yu came to Zhao's rescue and attacked the Qin army. Wang Li was indeed captured, and his army surrendered to the allied states.

The Grand Historian remarks: A common saying holds that 'the foot-rule has its shortcomings, and the inch-measure its strengths.' Bai Qi could read the enemy, adapt to changing conditions, and produce endless stratagems — his name shook the world. Yet he could not save himself from the Marquis of Ying's machinations. Wang Jian served as Qin's general and leveled the six states. In his time he was the most experienced of commanders, and the First Emperor deferred to him as a teacher. Yet he could not help Qin build virtue and secure its foundations — he chose to go along and please, merely to preserve himself. That his grandson Wang Li was captured by Xiang Yu — was that not fitting?

Each had his shortcoming.

Bai Qi and Wang Jian, both masters of war. Serving Qin in succession, they broke Qi and crushed Chu. Zhao trusted the son of Mafu; Changping's dead filled the pits. Chu overwhelmed Li Xin; from Bashang the old general marched at last. Ben and Li followed after — three generations, and the name was spent.

Notes

1person王離Wáng Lí

Wang Li (王離) was Wang Jian's grandson. His defeat at the Battle of Julu (207 BC) by Xiang Yu was one of the decisive moments in the fall of Qin. Xiang Yu's forces crossed the river, destroyed their cooking pots, and sank their boats — the origin of the idiom 破釜沉舟 ('smash the cauldrons and sink the boats'), meaning to commit oneself with no possibility of retreat.

2place

Julu (鉅鹿) was in modern Pingxiang County, Hebei. The Battle of Julu (207 BC) was the decisive battle that broke Qin's military power.

3context

The 'three generations of generals' theory reflects a fatalistic belief that military killing accumulates karmic debt. The guest's prediction serves Sima Qian's larger theme: military prowess alone cannot sustain a dynasty. Bai Qi's battlefield genius and Wang Jian's political cunning both failed to save their legacies because neither addressed Qin's fundamental lack of moral legitimacy.

4context

Sima Qian's verdict on Wang Jian — 偷合取容 ('going along to please') — is surprisingly harsh for a general who conquered most of the known world. The Grand Historian judges Wang Jian not by his military achievements but by his failure to moderate Qin's harshness or build lasting institutions. This reflects the Confucian view that a minister's highest duty is remonstrance, not obedience.

5person陳勝Chén Shèng

Chen Sheng (陳勝, d. 208 BC) was a commoner who led the first major rebellion against the Qin dynasty in 209 BC. His uprising, described in Shiji ch. 48, began the chain of events that destroyed the dynasty Wang Jian had built.

Edition & Source

Text
《史記》 Shiji
Edition
中華古詩文古書籍網 transcription
Commentary
裴駰《史記集解》、司馬貞《史記索隱》、張守節《史記正義》(Three Commentaries)